I-9 Form Audit Checklist

I-9 audits are essential for maintaining accurate employment records and ensuring compliance with immigration regulations. The U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services issues the I-9 form to verify employment eligibility, making these audits crucial for avoiding penalties and maintaining legal compliance.

This comprehensive checklist guides HR professionals through the I-9 audit process, helping ensure thorough verification and documentation of employment eligibility.

The checklist includes reviewing each I-9 for accuracy, ensuring all required fields are completed, verifying acceptable forms of identification, and confirming that forms are stored separately from personnel files.

Regular I-9 audits also help identify and correct errors proactively, ensure proper retention and disposal timelines, and demonstrate due diligence in the event of a government inspection or audit.

Compliance Rate

98% accuracy in verified audits

Documentation

100% required verification

Retention Period

3+ years after hire date

I-9 Audit Stages

Internal Audit Preparation

Establish clear audit strategy and gather necessary resources.

Access to complete personnel files
Understanding of I-9 requirements
Detailed audit execution plan
Designated audit team members

Conducting Internal Audit

Thorough review of each employee's I-9 documentation.

Verify form completeness
Check supporting documents
Identify discrepancies
Document findings systematically

Error Correction

Address and rectify identified issues.

Communicate with employees
Provide correction guidance
Track remediation progress
Maintain correction logs

Audit Finalization

Complete the audit process and secure documentation.

Review corrected forms
Organize audit records
Secure documentation storage
Prepare summary report

Best Practices for I-9 Compliance

Employee Onboarding

Complete Section 1 on day one
Verify original documents
Train onboarding staff

Record Management

Centralized storage system
Regular file maintenance
Proper retention periods

Training & Policies

Regular staff training
Clear written procedures
Updated compliance guides

Electronic Systems

Compliant E-Verify usage
Secure digital storage
Automated reminders

Sample I-9 Audit Checklist

Section 1 Review

Employee name and other personal information complete
Citizenship/immigration status properly indicated
Employee signature and date present
Preparer/translator certification if applicable

Section 2 Verification

Document titles match acceptable document list
Document numbers and expiration dates recorded
Employer certification properly completed
Timely completion within 3 business days

Section 3 Reverification

Expired document updates completed
Name changes properly recorded
Rehire information accurately documented
New expiration dates tracked

Frequently Asked Questions

How often should I-9 audits be conducted?

Best practice is to conduct internal I-9 audits at least annually. Companies with higher turnover or in industries with increased scrutiny may benefit from more frequent reviews.

How should I handle I-9 corrections?

Draw a line through incorrect information, enter correct information, initial and date the correction. Never use correction fluid or tape. If Section 2 needs correction, the employer representative should make the changes.

What is the I-9 retention requirement?

Retain I-9 forms for three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later. Calculate the retention date for each terminated employee to ensure compliance.

What are common I-9 audit findings?

Common issues include missing signatures, incorrect dates, incomplete sections, expired documents, missing reverification, and improper corrections. Regular self-audits help identify and correct these issues.

What triggers an I-9 inspection?

ICE inspections can be triggered by tips, leads, random selection, or as part of broader investigations. Having a robust I-9 compliance program helps prepare for potential government audits.

;